This review covers specifically the services of acting as a real estate agent for a rental property, not the for the purchase and sale of a property. In mid-January, my husband and I found a few rental properties listed on Zillow in Montclair, NJ. Jerry Sahlman was the listing agent at two of the properties so we contacted him. The only positive thing I can say about him is that Mr. Sahlman got back to us immediately. In total Mr. Sahlman showed us five rentals, including one which he co-owns (on Brookfield Ave.), which he showed us first. With each the subsequent rental he showed us he would aggressively push his own property claiming it was the best value. In reality, his house was overpriced compared to the others. When we noted the water pooling in parts of the basement of his rental, he acknowledged the house was in a flood zone but that he had sump pumps to take the water out. When we pointed out the peeling paint on the walls, he said he woud not repaint the apartment but would do some 'touch-ups'. He remained so aggressive with the idea that we should take his property that he did not want to show me an apartment on The Crescent, claiming that I wouldn't like it. He went as far as to insist to my husband that we shouldn't see it. Unfortunately for him, I don't like to be told what I'm going to like or not. I make my mind up for myself. He finally gave into showing us the apartment on The Crescent. As we parted from the last showing, I mentioned to my husband that we were close to a restaurant I wanted to go to for a late lunch (for privacy reasons, the restaurant shall remain nameless). Mr. Sahlman mentioned that the owner of that restaurant, had recently purchased a building but didn't have any apartments to show at the time. I thanked him for his time, told him we'd be in touch in a couple of days to let him know if we were interested in any of the apartments he'd shown us. When we arrived at the restaurant it was packed. I texted my ex-neighbor to let her know we were in the area and see if she and her family wanted to join us. The restaurant was so full we decided to go two doors down to a pizzeria instead. As my neighbor approached, I waved to her and her husband (who I saw walking with a friend). As luck would have it, the friend they were walking with was the owner of the restaurant. I told my neighbors how we'd been looking at different apts that morning. My neighbor's husband said that the friend they'd been walking with owned several properties and he'd be willing to ask him if he had any available. To make a long story short (I know too late at this point), it was my neigbor that made the introduction to the property owning restaurateur. The restaurateur was very pleasant and told us he would have an apt come available in February, we were very excited because it was along Bloomfield Ave.I called Mr. Sahlman the next day, I told him we were still interested in one of rentals he had shown us, but that we had met restaurateur through our mutual friend the previous day. Mr. Sahlman said that if we rented any apartmentfrom the restaurateur we'd have to go through him because of the conversation from the previous day. He said that he listed all the apartments for the guy and that the guy was "loyal" to him. I thought, what is this....the Godfather?. And even at this point Mr. Sahlman was insisting that I wouldn't like the restaurateur's apartment, that it was too small for my needs....yada yada yada and that I should take his property on Brookfield. I finally had to tell him that I wasn't interested in his apartment since he wasn't getting the hint. I was uneasy with the entire situation with Mr. Sahlman but was willing to pay the commission even though I didn't think it was fair since (1) he never showed us any property belonging to the restaurateur and (2) we'd actually met him through a mutual friend. At the end, the restaurateur now refuses to rent to us because Mr. Sahlman lied. Mr. Sahlman told the restaurant owner that he had sent us to his establishment to meet him, which he never did. So now the restaurant owner thinks we lied to him because we didn't tell him that Jerry had sent us, again that's not how things happened. Mr. Sahlman is untrustworthy, aggressive and self-serving. Mr. Sahlman never told us the name of the owner, did not show us picture or gave us any information about the apartment nor did he make any effort to contact the owner to set up a visit.

| Property Address | Details |
|---|---|
![]() Montclair Twp., NJ 07043 | Bed(s): 6 Bath(s): 4 sqft: 7,174 |
![]() Montclair Twp., NJ 07042 | 3 Story(s) | 0 sqft | 0 Office SqFt |
![]() Montclair Twp., NJ 07042 | 0 Building(s) | 0 sqft | 0 Units |
| Property Address | Details |
|---|---|
Parsippany-troy Hills Twp., NJ 07034 | Bed(s): 4 Bath(s): 2 |
City Of Orange Twp., NJ 07050 | Bed(s): 3 Bath(s): 1 |